Comparison

Professional Authoring Tools

DoStudio Authoring Suite (DSA) is a professional BD-ROM specification compliant tool designed for ease of authoring and maximum playback performance. Due to DSA’s high-end feature set, it competes with Sonic Scenarist BD and Sony Blu-print for high-end uses such as Hollywood studio titles. DoStudio, Scenarist and Blu-print are the only tools that are reliable for Blu-ray discs that go to replication. Other than the obvious cost difference, the power of DSA lies in its streamlined workflow and speed of authoring.

NetBlender DSA

Sony
Blu-print

Sonic Scenarist BD 4.5

Blu-ray Specification
BD-50 (dual-layer) support

Managed Copy support

HDMV-only Support

Native BD-J output

with on-Q Create

Planned BD-Live Support

Picture-in-Picture Support

Slideshows

Support for all three HD codecs (AVC/H.264, VC-1, and MPEG-2)

HD Audio support: DD+ (Dolby Digital), DTS-HD (Digital Theatre Sound), Dolby True HD, Dolby Digital, MLP and LPCM.

BD Authoring
Manage Elements using Abstractions

Flexible Docking windows

Drag & Drop authoring

No Scripting!

Menu Design & Graphics
Pop-up Menus (Out-of-mux Interactive Graphics Support)

Animated menu effects

Button Sound Effects

PSD importing included

Image-based Subtitles Support

Import Subtitle File

32 bit Menu graphics

with on-Q Create

WYSIWYG Menu design

Mastering & Replication
BDCMF Version

1.01

1.01

1.01

Sony CMF Formatting

AACS Support

Prosumer Authoring Tools

At the other end of the feature-set and cost spectrum are the following prosumer level Blu-ray authoring tools. These tools are inexpensive, easy to use and familiar to DVD authors, however they do not create full-featured Blu-ray discs. The primary difference between the prosumer level tools and DoStudio is their lack of support for pop-up menus, picture-in-picture, and BD-J. These tools create DVD-style menu structures with high-definition video content rather than “Hollywood-style” Blu-ray discs.

Adobe
Encore

Sonic
DVDit Pro HD

Sony
Vegas

Blu-ray Specification
BD-50 (dual-layer) support

Managed Copy support

BD-J Support

Planned BD-Live Support

Picture-in-Picture Support

Slideshows

Support for all three HD codecs (AVC/H.264, VC-1, and MPEG-2)

HD Audio support: DD+ (Dolby Digital), DTS-HD (Digital Theatre Sound), Dolby True HD, Dolby Digital, MLP and LPCM.

LPCM only

Menu Design & Graphics
Pop-up Menus (Out-of-mux Interactive Graphics Support)

Button Sound Effects

PSD importing included

Image & Text-based Subtitles Support

Import Subtitle File

WYSIWYG Menu design

Mastering & Replication
BDCMF Support

Sony CMF Formatting

AACS Support